The FIRST Skymaster Fly-in was in 2002 in Treasure Cay, Abacos, Bahamas. That is always a good destination.
In 2005 the Fly-in was in Key West but there was a side-trip to Great Harbour Cay in the Bahama's Berry Islands.
The latter is closer to Florida (140 nm), great beaches, not as well known, therefore less choice in restaurants, etc. However, I have had a house there and have been going for the last 15 years, so that's an advantage if we do it there.
For more on the island, see
www.consultresearch.com/GHC2.htm
Ernie Martin