Skymaster Forum

Skymaster Forum (http://www.337skymaster.com/messages/index.php)
-   Messages (http://www.337skymaster.com/messages/forumdisplay.php?f=1)
-   -   Unknown item in W&B (http://www.337skymaster.com/messages/showthread.php?t=4712)

JimC 07-10-20 06:07 PM

Unknown item in W&B
 
I'm looking through my old W&B docs, and I found this line item in the original factory W&B:

"MODEL 337TURBO SUPER SKYMASTR" [sic]
Weight: 159.0 lbs
Arm: 115.5

The airframe itself is listed as "STANDARD AIRPLANE (EMPTY,DRY,UNPAINTED) ACTUAL" with a weight of 2617.5 and an arm of 141.6.

Does anyone know what that 159 lb item is? Is that the factory way of listing the turbo system? I find it odd that they'd build it, weigh it, and *then* add turbos.


At some point my c.g. jumped over an inch and a half forward and I'm trying to find out when & why. It's currently 137.5, which seems VERY far forward. I go out of c.g. with two people and 1/2 fuel. It's been as far forward as 137.2, which seems to me to be dangerously far forward. It came from the factory at 138.9. The w&b that moved it from 138.9 to 137.2 is missing.

JAG 07-11-20 03:39 PM

weight
 
1 Attachment(s)
Jim,
Look closely at the original factor W&B - many times the aircraft was "computed" and not "actual" weight - that could explain the turbo system being listed separate. See snap shot of my original - it calculated the paint! depending on your configuration, they are all listed in the equipment list with annotations either as installed (have an 'x') and whether it is optional or required equipment.

My guess is the 159 lbs is the extra weight for you aircraft as optioned over the standard airplane weight.

Jeff

JimC 07-11-20 06:22 PM

1 Attachment(s)
Mine's listed as ACTUAL. Also, each piece of installed equipment is listed separately.

The 159 lb item in question is the last line item. The station of 115.5 is slightly forward of the average of the two engines (the average station of oil is 125.5.)

JimC 07-11-20 06:49 PM

BTW, I found all but one of my missing W&Bs. The one where the weight seems to "jump" forward is a reweighing from about 30 years ago. The weight and c.g move as though 111.5 lbs were added right about at the pilot's knees. That's a lot of "found" weight, and very far forward. Every W&B since then has been a calculation off of that one.

I don't think the 1990 reweighing was done precisely.

JAG 07-13-20 08:58 AM

Thanks Jim,
Interesting to see your W&B from Cessna from 1969. Mine is about 5 pages, and it is similar in the sense - but it also includes the whole equipment list for all 1966 aircraft, then and 'X' or 'O' depending on if it was installed.

I was worried about the same on my my aircraft - for the last 30 years the W&B had been amended, but I was concerned about the actual weight and CofG. My reweigh went well, and right about where I thought it would be. I removed a lot of old stuff, but added a bit with a lot of soundproofing/insulation in the cabin. Nose scale was 390 lbs, LH main 1249 lbs and RH main 1243 lbs = 2882 lbs. I weighed with fuel empty, but oil full.

Cof G is 140.2 inches.

Jeff

TomM 07-13-20 03:54 PM

Its interesting how the static wicks are negligible but post lights are worth weighing and calculating moment arm.........I cant imagine the post lights weigh more than the static wicks....

hharney 07-13-20 05:00 PM

My empty CG is 141.39

https://rgl.faa.gov/Regulatory_and_Guidance_Library/rgMakeModel.nsf/0/a64682a24c2ce51086257ed700622c0f/$FILE/A6CE_Rev_41.pdf

JimC 07-13-20 10:24 PM

Mine was 137.08 at one point. That's a massive difference for similar model airplanes. I've surveyed 6 owners and I haven't found anyone farther forward than about 139.7. Most are 140 to 141.

137.08 has to be an error. I'll know by the end of next month. Until then, I'm loading it with a load that is in c.g. for both 137.7 (my current c.g.) and an arbitrarily picked 141.0. It just generally means throwing a bunch of extra stuff behind the rear seats. That way I'm safe whether it's wrong or right.

JAG 07-15-20 08:54 AM

Hi Jim,
I just looked back at your other thread, and one thing I noticed is the measurements you had for calculating the CofG.

When I measured my points, I came up with:
A (front face of Fwd Firewall to main wheel centers) = 87.8 "
B (Nose Wheel center to main wheel center) = 93.7 "
I took a great deal of time doing the measurements using a plumb bob, tape on the floor, large straight edges, etc. Still easy to mess it up though...

The last W&B on my aircraft had the following measurements: A=88.5" B=94"

You indicated in your last post that they had 96" for B. That may be an error (I am only guessing), and a larger number for that measurement will move the C of G forward.

I would hope all of our early model 337's have the same measurements, but it can change a little (1/4" maybe) depending on who measures and how tight the rigging is on the gear.

Let us know how the next weighing goes and what you find out. One last thing is to move the scales around when you weigh it. When I weighed mine, I jacked the aircraft to set it on the scales. Even though they were calibrated scales, I weighed it a second time (jacked it back up and set it down again) after moving the scales to a different position, just to make sure there was no difference in how they read.

Hope this helps.

Jeff

JimC 07-15-20 06:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JAG (Post 25020)
When I measured my points, I came up with:
A (front face of Fwd Firewall to main wheel centers) = 87.8 "
B (Nose Wheel center to main wheel center) = 93.7 "
I took a great deal of time doing the measurements using a plumb bob, tape on the floor, large straight edges, etc. Still easy to mess it up though...

[...]

Hope this helps.

Jeff

It helps tremendously. All I know at this point is that it's very likely wrong. Knowing where it's likely wrong will help me sleep at night. I figured the linear measurements were off - there was no effort made to record a precision of less than one inch. Also, the the weight of my front tire was recorded as 500.0 lbs, exactly. Is it possible? Yes, but I think it's more likely they were using a substandard scale with a precision of 10.0 lbs. Combine that with substandard measurement and you have my W&B.

What REALLY shocks me is that this has been the reference W&B for 30+ years! Either
a) nobody checked c.g. or
b) nobody thought having two 170 lb pilots throw the plane out of c.g. was unusual!

JimC 06-16-21 06:02 PM

Well, it took almost a year - but I had my plane accurately weighed. As expected, I gained 60+ lbs of useful load and the c.g. moved back almost two inches. I'm still trying to figure out why the c.g. is slightly forward more than the fleet average - I'm at 139.38.

This error has been in the paperwork of the plane for over 30 years!

patrolpilot 06-17-21 10:09 PM

My '77G just weighed in at 3068 @ 140.

Learjetter 06-18-21 12:56 AM

Paperwork says I’m at 2968 @ 141.1 ‘77 G model.

But I’m going to weigh her this fall and get an accurate updated W&B.

JimC 06-18-21 06:48 PM

Those G models are light! I can't figure out how they're lighter than the Es and Fs, when they have the same fuselage as a P-model.

JAG 06-30-21 03:47 PM

Jim - what is your empty weight? E & F should be lighter than the G given the different interior...

Jeff

JimC 07-22-21 10:55 AM

I've come to the conclusion that the unknown item in my W&B is the weight of the entire turbo system, which was installed after my airplane was weighed at the factory.

If the 2968 lbs is correct, that is a VERY light plane. I still can't figure out where I'm "fat" - the turbo is about 150 lbs, and that G is lighter than my plane minus the turbo. The 3068 lb G seems more likely.

My empty weight is 3,174 lbs.

Learjetter 07-22-21 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by JimC (Post 27022)
I've come to the conclusion that the unknown item in my W&B is the weight of the entire turbo system, which was installed after my airplane was weighed at the factory.

If the 2968 lbs is correct, that is a VERY light plane. I still can't figure out where I'm "fat" - the turbo is about 150 lbs, and that G is lighter than my plane minus the turbo. The 3068 lb G seems more likely.

My empty weight is 3,174 lbs.

I have contiguous W&B calculation forms from various upgrades over the years, including the factory-as-delivered equipment list with its W&B. The math adds up to 2968.

But, I’ll do a proper W&B this winter and it’ll check out right, or wrong—either way we’ll have a good W&B for 2022.

PS: I have MT props (supposedly 30lbs lighter each than stock props).


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 10:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.